Saturday, June 30, 2012

POWASSAN RESIDENTS FIGHT WIND FARM

NEWS RELEASE

POWASSAN RESIDENTS FIGHT WIND FARM


Powassan – A visibly distraught Barb Ashbee spoke with passion about what her family endured when wind turbines came to her home town. Ashbee was one of three speakers at a town hall event hosted by STOMP (Stop Turbines On Maplehill Powassan) last night to highlight the negative impacts a proposed industrial wind farm could have on the community.

Bruce Lourie's Spider Web Grows and catches more Prey and Tax Dollars

Click to view (click here for .pdf)
An article I wrote in May 2012 identified the extent of Bruce Lourie's reach into the world of climate change/renewable energy through a plethora of charities, not-for-profit and for profit entities that he founded or where he exerts influence. This was elaborated on with a follow-up article that looked at a three of the companies he founded and attempted to trace some of the millions of taxpayer dollars that have found their way to those three. Included with the latter was a spider web that attempted to trace the connections and the money flow.

This piece will look at two more of the Lourie creations which are; The Sustainability Network and the Canadian Environmental Grantmakers Network (CEGN).

Reviewing the Sustainability Network's website is an exercise in trying to define what they are trying to accomplish. The focus becomes somewhat clearer after reading what they see as their mission referred to as: “ Our mission is to enrich Canadian environmental leaders and nonprofit organizations through programs, services and support that help them increase their capacity to lead, manage and strategize.” ...and , “We are about sustaining the organizations that work on sustainability.”

Friday, June 29, 2012

County wants to see wind developer's money

 Another council looks at fees to prevent costs piling up on unwilling municipalities, along with industrial wind turbines. 

Orangeville Article: County wants to see wind developer's money
“If the company wants us to proceed on their behalf and look at their proposals, I think we should be reimbursed appropriately,” he said. “The costs of us trying to find all the answers are accumulating. In the end, if we don’t grab it, we’re going to be stuck with the bill.”
Reimbursement wasn’t the only issue county council tackled that night, as Shelburne Deputy Mayor Ken Bennington submitted a planning report from his town, as well as a motion from his municipality and a petition signed by residents opposing the wind developer’s proposal.
Town staff conducted an inventory of existing and proposed sensitive land uses along the proposed transmission corridor in Shelburne. There are about 106 existing or proposed dwellings with 150 feet of the wind developer’s proposed hydro line — Hyland Heights Elementary School and a public park also abut the rail corridor.
Referring to a restriction in California forbidding any new elementary schools or schoolyards within 45 metres of a 230 KV transmission line, Bennington urged county councillors to cease negotiations.
The full Orangeville.com article also notes the requirements in some jurisdictions to bury cables

Clearview Calls for another wind turbine meeting

Clearview Township Councillor Brent Preston introduced a successful resolution that called on Skyway 124 to hold another public meeting claiming violation of "two key stipulations in the Green Energy Act."
"One is they have to provide notice [of a public meeting] to all landowners within 120 metres of the project. The notice must be in writing and they failed to do that. There are at least two landowners who haven't been notified of either public meeting," Preston explains. "But the biggest problem is as part of the public meeting they have to present their project plan...which includes a map of the project area. And at the first public meeting they didn't even show turbine locations and at the second meeting they showed turbine locations but the really key thing they have to show is the location of all the noise receptors. So a noise receptor is either a house or a location on a vacant lot that would be deemed a residence. And there are just dozens and dozens of errors and omissions on their mapping."
Read the entire article at Simcoe.com

Bank's local-content audit 'could destroy Brazil's wind industry'

A foreign nation's wind industry thrived under financing rules, but is crippled by an audit to ensure compliance. 

Bank's local-content audit 'could destroy Brazil's wind industry' - Recharge:
Brazil’s main lender to wind farms has revoked finance authorisation for projects using Vestas, Suzlon, Fuhrländer, Clipper and Acciona turbines, after auditing manufacturers to see if they comply with local-content regulations.
“The entire industry is stopped” as a result of the actions of BNDES, the national development bank

Thursday, June 28, 2012

Final HAF wind project public meeting gets noisy

The West Lincoln Glanbrook Wind Action Group utilized weather balloons and cookware in raising local awareness

“I came out here for the peace and quiet. I can see all kinds of wildlife from my backyard — deer, coyotes, all kinds. And now I am going to see these big towers.”
The man was able to better visualize just how tall those turbines will be thanks to a public awareness campaign launched Saturday by the West Lincoln Glanbrook Wind Action Group, a citizen’s group which opposes wind energy.
This past Saturday, the group raised several weather balloons to the height of the proposed wind turbines, to provide a sense of scale for the size of the storeys-high towers. The wind turbines to be installed across the municipality will be as tall as 145 metres. WLWAG is calling the campaign “Look Up, Wake Up.”
“We raised the balloons to help people visualize just how tall these turbines are going to be,” said Cam Pritchard, spokesperson for the group. “A lot of people can’t envision how tall 145 feet is. There were a lot of people on the border line, who weren’t sure if they were for or against the turbines, and when they saw the balloons, it really hit home for them.”

McGuinty's MUSH[y] Tax

The University of Western Ontario's (UWO) publication, Western News, recently published a news item about their annual electricity bill. The bill for UWO was reported as $25 million in 2011 and the writer incorrectly blamed 25% of that bill on what they called a Global Adjustment (GA) “tax”. The author tried to explain what the GA represented but many of the facts were wrong. One thing the writer was correct on was that UWO was a “Class A” customer, because they consume in excess of 5,000 kWh per month-the cutoff point for large users.

Class A and B customers were created after lobbying by the Association of Major Power Consumers in Ontario (42 members) but the benefits of this classification didn't come into play until January 1, 2011. Class A customers are able to reduce their costs of electricity by picking 5 peak demand hours that occur over a 12 month period, This task can be predicted with relative accuracy by looking at Ontario's electricity peak demand patterns which occur on hot days in the summer in the hours close to dinner. Once the hours are picked the Class A customer can fire up the diesel backup generator to reduce their demand on the grid and the shift is complete. As Aegent Energy reported the shift in 2011 reduced the GA Class A customers paid by $10.97 a MW or 28.7% less then they would have paid under the previous system. This shift reduced the Class A customer's share of the GA while increasing the share paid by Class B ratepayers. For 2011 that shift cost Class B ratepayers $225 million. The amount of that shift will increase in the current year as the GA pot grows to over $7 billion from $5.1 billion in 2011. For 2012 the shift will be over $300 million and close to 40% less for the Class A consumers under the old system.

Norfolk Council Buckles/Compomises on Conditions for transmission cable burial

... projects like this have a habit of changing hands numerous times. When that happens, liability is dispersed and reliable maps of underground utilities become hard to find. D’Hondt fears the municipality will be left holding the bag if anything goes wrong.

“Tracking down firms has been a problem for us,” he said. “Not only for the old stuff, but for the new stuff.”

Capital Power executives Anthony Zlahtic and Barry Loewen brought the issue to council’s attention. They told council that encasing the 3.4 kilometres of cable in concrete would put the $70-million project behind schedule while adding $1 million to the final construction cost.

The pair said in-ground burial is standard for projects of this kind, adding that the 51-kilometres of collector cable in Haldimand will be buried without a concrete casing.

“We’re a little frustrated with where we’re at,” Zlahtic said.

In a 4-3 decision, council agreed to let Capital Power bury its cable without a casing. However, the firm must do so to a depth of two metres. This is double the provincial standard. As well, the collector cable’s location will have to be clearly marked.
Read The Entire Article at the Simcoe Reformer site

Robert Bryce: Economists Without Calculators

Robert Bryce: Economists Without Calculators:
"Between 1985 and 2011, global electricity generation increased by about 450 terawatt-hours per year. That’s the equivalent of adding about one Brazil (which used 485 terawatt-hours of electricity in 2010) to the electricity sector every year. And the International Energy Agency expects global electricity use to continue growing by about one Brazil per year through 2035..."

Ontario’s Power Trip: Discounts and windmills

Tom Adams article communicates the growing division between large user pricing, and residential/small business electricity pricing - due to the feed-in tariff, global adjustment, and newly announced industrial rate policies of the McGuinty government.

Ontario’s Power Trip: Discounts and windmills | FP Comment | Financial Post:
While offering industry rates at 5.5¢ per kWh, the government is at the same time committing non-preferred consumers — smaller businesses and retail consumers — to pay rates that start at 11.5¢ per kWh for more wind power and 34.7¢ per kWh for solar. The government’s wind and solar contracts contain escalators and they require guaranteed payments to generators for curtailed production and costly new transmission and backup power.

Kingston neighbors of wind turbines complain of ill effects

Another community experiences the effects of industrial wind turbines ...

Kingston neighbors of wind turbines complain of ill effects - Brockton, MA - The Enterprise:
"Neighbors of Kingston’s new wind turbines made plenty of noise at a zoning board of appeals hearing, sharing stories with panel members about sleepless nights and anxiety caused by the turbines.
Leland Road resident Dan Alves, speaking at a hearing last week, said he knew there had been talk of wind turbines before they were built, but he was not informed about what it would really mean to have them near his home.
“Never would I have experienced what I have experienced – headaches, dizziness, vertigo,” Alves said. “It sounds like a 747 that never lands.”

Continue Reading at The Enterprise news site:

Tuesday, June 26, 2012

3 wind-turbine failures firefighters must know

3 wind-turbine failures firefighters must know | Ontario Association of Fire Chiefs:
 3 wind-turbine failures firefighters must know - Wind-turbine farms are springing up across the country and they pose unique threats to fire and rescue agencies.

Wind-farms have been around for several decades in Europe, but only in recent years have we seen them appear in the United States. The United Kingdom has experienced a dramatic increase in wind-turbine incidents resulting in a number of civilian injuries and deaths in the past decade, according to a report by Caithness Windfarm Information Forum 2012.

Powassan wind farm opponents gather steam

Powassan wind farm opponents gather steam - The North Bay Nugget - Ontario, CA:
The potential health, environmental and financial effects of industrial wind turbines will be discussed at a public meeting Thursday at the Powassan Legion.

A citizens' group called Stop Turbines on Maplehill Powassan (STOMP) has arranged for guest speakers.

Anemos Energy Corp. had sought council support for the Maple Hill Wind Project proposal earlier this year, but was denied until there are more details available.

Guest speakers will include Nipissing MPP and Progressive Conservative Energy Critic Vic Fedeli, Barbara Ashbee of the Victims of Wind and Carmen Krogh.
Read the full article at The North Bay Nugget website:

Wind opponents generate dissension | Better Farming

The Better Farming has coverage of the first of Pembina's horse and turbine shows with Heidi Eijgel, in Grand Bend.

Wind opponents generate dissension | Better Farming:
The turbine closest to her home is 700 metres away and her pictures showed vast open spaces with no homes or development of any kind in sight. About the only contentious issue in her wind-turbine experience was the threat of overhead transmission lines. In the end, the company that developed the project in her neighborhood agreed to bury transmission lines, something she said she and her neighbors fought for...
The most effective anti-wind speaker was Norma Schmidt who lives near Kincardine. She said she and her husband welcomed the idea of sustainable wind development when it was first proposed. However, when their 13-acre property was surrounded by turbines – none on their land – she became ill and was hospitalized, something she attributes to the wind development.
“Our life is hell,” she said. “We don’t have a life. Thirty-three years of hard work is all misery now. There is a madness going on in Ontario now. They are destroying our lives.”
.The entire article can be read on the Better Farming website:

US Federal Agencies Sued Over Failure to Disclose Correspondence with Wind Industry

Federal Agencies Sued Over Failure to Disclose Correspondence with Wind Industry - Promise of Government Transparency Not Being Met:
Picture from source article (ABC)
(Washington, D.C., June 26, 2012) In a lawsuit filed today in Washington D.C. District Court American Bird Conservancy has accused the federal government of suppressing information about wind energy projects and their potential negative impact on America's wildlife. ABC is being represented in the suit by the Washington D.C. public-interest law firm of Meyer Glitzenstein & Crystal.

ABC charges that two Interior Department (DOI) agencies flagrantly violated the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) by failing to comply with statutory deadlines for disclosure of information, and by failing to provide their correspondence with wind developers and other information related to potential impacts on birds and bats, and bird and bat deaths at controversial wind developments in 10 states.

"It’s ridiculous that Americans have to sue in order to find out what their government is saying to wind companies about our wildlife—a public trust,” said Kelly Fuller, Wind Campaign Coordinator for ABC. “ABC is concerned that many of these projects have the potential to take a devastating toll on songbirds, majestic eagles, and threatened and endangered species,” she added.
Read the entire article at the American Bird Conservancy Website:

Meaford Council to Wind Developers: You're Not Welcome Here

After months of hearing residents ask that Meaford's council take a public stand with regard to the potential for industrial wind turbine developments within the municipality, council last night delivered what many had been asking for.
Meaford Council to Wind Developers: You're Not Welcome Here:
“Whereas the Municipality of Meaford is currently faced with an Industrial Wind Turbine Farm application in and around what is known as Silcote corners; and Whereas a substantial number of our residents, from all corners of our community, have voiced opposition to the acceptance of this project, and, whereas troublesome negative effects, such as adverse health effects, decrease in property values, destruction of the natural view-scape, and overall deterioration in individual quality of life are feared by near and far neighbours of this proposed site; and Whereas the Council of the Municipality of Meaford frustratingly acknowledges that any decision they make cannot overrule the powers given by the province in the Green Energy Act...
Now Therefore, regardless of the undemocratic terms of Ontario Bill 150, be it resolved that the Council of the Municipality of Meaford confirms that it is not desirous of any Industrial Wind turbine development within our corporation, and requests that developers of wind farms do not submit further applications within our municipal boundaries,” 
Read the report in the Meaford Independent:

How is Creating Green Jobs Like Banning Tractors to Create Farm Jobs?

How is Creating Green Jobs is Like Banning Tractors to Create Farm Jobs? | Clearing the Air | NCPA.org:
Graphic from source article
...the best option of all – generating electricity using bicycle generators. Pedaling ten hours a day on a stationary bike, each person can generate 1 kWh. Investing $1 million in bicycle generators and paying people the going rate for the energy they create, we could create 1,610 jobs....

The reason solar power creates more jobs per $1 million is that solar is extremely inefficient, requiring more workers to do more as they produce less. We could easily apply this to other sectors.

If we want to create more farm jobs (after all the percentage of farm jobs in the economy has fallen dramatically in the last century), we could ban tractors. Think of all the jobs we’d create for farm workers!
 Read the entire article at the National Center for Policy Analysis Website:

Questions persist about NextEra's Bluewater project

 “Everyone is nervous because of the known..."

Questions persist about NextEra project | Local | News | Lakeshore Advance:
Gerhard, his wife Heather, and their family milk 350 cows three times a day. They are concerned about stray voltage and how the transmission lines will affect their business.
“Our livelihood is at risk,” said Heather Ritzema. “We have to weigh those risks.”
“If there is an oil leak, then the company is responsible for cleaning up that leak, if there is stray voltage, are they going to fix it?” asked Gerhard.
“Because of the number of dairy farmers on the transmission route, we have tried to go above and beyond to explain the issues to every person on the route to address in advance any concerns they might have about stray voltage,” said Nicole Geneau, project manager of the Bluewater project.
“Everyone is nervous because of the known..."
The article can be read at the Lakeshore Advance website:

Sheep dog affected by wind turbine wake pressure?

A story, originating in Australia, indicates working dogs are being impacted by industrial wind turbines

aeinews.org: Sheep dog affected by wind turbine wake pressure?:
...the wind farm company requested that a vet examine the dog after the owner contacted them about a dramatic behavior change in one of his working sheep dogs after nights in which the wind blew from the turbine direction. Like many human reports, the effect occurs only in particular wind conditions; I wonder whether it’s similar to some wind farm neighbors who experience ear pressure and popping when downwind from turbines, perhaps due to air pressure differentials in the turbine wake, or due to a particularly strong physiological reaction to low frequency noise. Many other reports of effects on farm animals have been more general, making it hard to preclude other possible causes.
Read the entire article at The Acoustic Ecology Institute website:

Minnesota Court approves smaller Goodhue wind setbacks

The Minnesota Court of Appeals has sided with the wind developer in overriding local setback regulations for the proposed Goodhue industrial wind development.  With the impact on people being set aside, the proposal still faces hurdles in gaining permission to harm wildlife.

aeinews.org: Court approves smaller Goodhue wind setbacks; hurdles remain:
Strangely, the Court said that it had seen the 10 rotor diameter rule as a “zero-exposure standard;” in fact, a half mile would not avoid audibility or ocassionaly intrusive noise , especially at night, though it would reduce the number of homes experiencing relatively louder sound exposures. There are roughly 200 homes within the 1600 to 2700 foot zone. Many of the more substantial negative impacts reported by wind farm neighbors occur in this range.

While National Wind, developer of the 78-megawatt project, aims to begin construction within weeks, in hopes of being operational by the end of the year in order to qualify for expiring production tax credits, hurdles remain. The PUC rejected the company’s eagle monitoring and protections plan in February, and the developers have been planning to obtain an optional take permit from the US Fish and Wildlife Service to protect themselves in the event of that a bald eagle may be killed.
The full report at the Acoustic Ecology Institute site includes links to local, Minnesota, coverage.

South Marysburgh July 14 referendum on wind turbines

The County Coalition for Safe and Appropriate Green Energy (CCSAGE) has a post today noting South Marysburgh is holding a referendum (for local residents only - tax bill required)

South Marysburgh July 14 referendum on wind turbines: CCSAGE pec wind turbine news #1 source:
The South Marysburgh Mirror is sponsoring a referendum for S.M. residents on the subject of wind turbines. The question to be asked has not yet been announced, but will be straightforward and require only a Yes or No answer.

Voting will be limited to S.M. residents, permanent or seasonal, age 18 or better, and will take place at the Milford Town Hall on Saturday, July 14 from 9 am to 4 pm.

You can read more about the referendum in an article by publisher Steve Ferguson on the Mirror’s website. And Steve Campbell has some thoughts to share on his blog at CountyLive.

Monday, June 25, 2012

McGuinty's “Chicken or Egg” Clean Energy Strategy—The Lourie Influence


April 12, 2012 was an eventful day in the eyes of the McGuinty government with a press release at 8.45 AM announcing the appointment of fourteen (14) “members of the Ontario Clean Energy Task Force (CETF) and then minutes later at 9.21 AM another release proclaimed the “McGuinty Government Launches Clean Energy Economic Development Strategy” (CEEDS). The second release declared CEEDS would “create even more new jobs in the clean energy sector.” and CETF would “help broaden Ontario's energy focus by facilitating collaboration within Ontario's clean energy industry to identify export markets, marketing opportunities and approaches to identify export markets,” and said CETF will include energy experts and “lead cleantech trade missions to support domestic manufacturers by showcasing Ontario's clean energy solution in key markets”.

All of the rhetoric was intriguing but the appointees to the CETF who will lead those offshore trade missions to “Asia, the Middle East and the United States” was something that is the key to creating exports so it is important to look at the appointees. That is examined in the following chart:

INTERIOR DEPT. REPORT SLAMS BLM FOR POOR MONITORING, LACK OF FINANCIAL ACCOUNTABILITY AT WIND AND SOLAR PROJECTS ON PUBLIC LANDS | East County Magazine

The U.S. Bureau of Land Management is reportedly doing a poor job of protecting the public's interests in managing/structuing renewable energy projects on public lands.  The report noted below deals with a couple of topics thus far beyond the interests of governments (and relevant to Ontario's "Renewable Energy on Crown Land Policy" currently in comment period on the Environmental Registry): bonding, monitoring, and enforcing compliance.

INTERIOR DEPT. REPORT SLAMS BLM FOR POOR MONITORING, LACK OF FINANCIAL ACCOUNTABILITY AT WIND AND SOLAR PROJECTS ON PUBLIC LANDS | East County Magazine:
"June 24, 2012 (Washington D.C.) – A scathing new report by the U.S. Department of Interior’s Inspector General highlights “significant failures” by the federal Bureau of Land Managment in its stewardship over more than 30,000 wind energy right-of-way (ROW) acres and another 31,000 acres of solar energy ROW sites. View the complete report at http://www.doioig.gov/images/stories/reports/pdf/CR-EV-BLM-0004-2010Public.pdf.
In addition, the report exposed “weakness in financial accountability and resource protection including obligations to protect the Government’s financial interest by collecting rental revenues, managing the bond process, and by appropriate monitoring and enforcing ROW requirements.”"
...
“Our review of wind project files revealed very little inspection documentation for wind projects and no monitoring plans,” the report found.
Read the entire article at the East County Magazine website:

Sunday, June 24, 2012

Balloon launch to protest wind power

West Lincoln weather balloon to be raised to height of turbine
In advance of the construction of IPC wind turbines across West Lincoln, a protest group is working to raise awareness by getting residents to raise their eyes. This weekend, the West Lincoln Wind Action Group (WLWAG) is raising a weather balloon to the height of a wind turbine, to provide a sense of scale for the size of the turbines. The wind turbines to be installed across the municipality will be as tall as 145 meters. WLWAG is calling the campaign “Look Up, Wake Up.”
“Most people can’t comprehend the size of the of the impending giant 475’ industrial wind turbines that will shortly be invading our rural West Niagara neighbourhood and negatively impacting our health, our homes, our families, our natural environment, our pocketbooks and our faith in truth and justice,” reads a media release from WLWAG.
IPC is planning to construct five wind turbines in locations around West Lincoln.
The entire article can be read at  the Niagara This Week site

HWC’s Appeal continues – Jun 25th | Haldimand Wind Concerns

HWC’s Appeal continues – Jun 25th | Haldimand Wind Concerns:

"HWC’s case at the Environmental Review Tribunal Hearing continues this week;
Monday, June 25 – Director Vic Schroter and NextEra project manager, Ben Greenhouse Tuesday, June 26 – MOE noise engineer, John Kowalewski
Update: MOE's witness Mr. Kowalewski  was able to testify on the 25th, and nothing is now scheduled for the 26th.

All these dates will be held at the Hagersville Community Centre (62 Main St. S., Hagersville) and regular starting time is 10 am. All hearings are open to the public and attendance is much appreciated.

This is the schedule as it stands now. Please keep checking the website for changes.

All donations would be greatly appreciated for this very critical legal challenge.

Friday, June 22, 2012

Elma-Mornington Residents Reject Wind Turbine Project in Survery

In a survey released today by the Elma-Mornington Concerned Citizens, residents of the area identified for the Invenergy Conestogo wind turbine project overwhelmingly rejected the project by 96% to 4%.
Details of the results and the survey methodology are provided in the attached press release. [PDF]

The survey was organized in response to a comment by Premier Dalton McGuinty indicating that he would be responsive to community input on renewable energy project such as wind turbines. Fifteen volunteers from the community group conducted a door-to-door survey of all residents living within the defined study area for the Invenergy Conestogo Wind Turbine Project over the period from June 7 to June 12. This time period immediately followed the two public information sessions run by Invenergy to explain their project to the community.

To the committee’s knowledge, this survey is the first attempt by any organization to actually collect the views of all of the residents of the affected community as part of the Renewal Energy Assessment process.
Premier McGuinty quote: "I've got all kinds of communities that want them ... I don't need the headaches that are associated with them going into communities that don't want them."

Invenergy Conestogo  Project Information

Liberals suffer reality blackout on electrcitiy usage | Toronto & GTA | News | Toronto Sun

Christana Blizzard notes the connection between reduced industrial activity and reduced demand.

Liberals suffer reality blackout on electrcitiy usage | Toronto & GTA | News | Toronto Sun:
Data From IESO 18-Month Outlook Table 3.3.3 (xls)
We cruised through this week’s record-breaking temperatures with only minor glitches.

And while the Liberal government of Dalton McGuinty would like you to believe it’s their energy policy that’s saved us, in fact it’s their economic development plan — or lack thereof — that’s freed up massive amounts of electricity.

This province has lost almost half a million manufacturing jobs since McGuinty came to power, so we just don’t need the same kind of generation we once did.

Worse, they were in industries such as auto companies, which provided good, high-paying jobs that had a multiplier effect in their communities.
 Read the Entire column at The Toronto Sun

The graphic is related to the article, "Liberal Shell Game - smart meters and conservation," by Parker Gallant and Scott Luft

Sunday Reflection: The truth about Germany and the 'clean energy economy' | WashingtonExaminer.com

A politically motivated  opinion piece, by Christopher Horner and Wolfgang Müller, makes a compelling case that their President's touting of Germany's successes with renewable energy is no wiser than his previous citing of Spain's was.

Sunday Reflection: The truth about Germany and the 'clean energy economy' | WashingtonExaminer.com:
...Germany's energy sector is under the most stress of any in the country. It is hemorrhaging jobs.

Its "green" manufacturing companies are serially going bankrupt. Others now have valuations near penny-stock levels, and many have fled high-cost Germany for China -- a nation whose own English-language media also recently admitted was giving up the green-jobs ghost as well, now that its best customers for the costly gadgets have gone broke.

Germany's staggering electricity costs are three times what Americans pay, and rising.

This is all due to the same energy transformation law that Obama heralds as America's way out of economic malaise. Since that law was first adopted in 2000, Germany's GDP has regularly grown at half the pace of America's. It is presently growing at 0.7 percent annually -- quite a model.

The entire Op-ed can be read at WashingtonExaminer.com:

The trouble with turbines: An ill wind

Nature has had article subtitled, "With turbines threatening some bird and bat populations, researchers are seeking ways to keep the skies safe for wildlife."   I noted the graphic informing building strikes kill maybe one billion birds annually ... maybe 100,000.
It also notes IWT supporter Iberdola saying “We have terabytes' worth of data..." and researchers responding they'd love to see it.

The trouble with turbines: An ill wind : Nature News & Comment:
Source: A Manville, US Fish and Wildlife Service
...the concern is that turbines threaten species that are already struggling, such as bats, which in North America have been hit hard by white-nose fungus. Another vulnerable group is raptors, which are slow to reproduce and favour the wind corridors that energy companies covet. “There are species of birds that are getting killed by wind turbines that do not get killed by autos, windows or buildings,” says Shawn Smallwood, an ecologist who has worked extensively in Altamont Pass, California, notorious for its expansive wind farms and raptor deaths. Smallwood has found that Altamont blades slay an average of 65 golden eagles a year.  “We could lose eagles in this country if we keep on doing this,” he says.

Other species at risk include the critically endangered California condors (Gymnogyps californicus) — which number only 226 in the wild — and the few hundred remaining whooping cranes (Grus americanus), concentrated in the central United States. Biologists can't say whether the increase in wind farms will cause the collapse of these or other bird species, which already face many threats. But waiting for an answer is not an option, says Smallwood. “By the time we do understand the population-level impacts, we might be in a place we don't want to be.”
The entire article can be read at the Nature website

Meaford Prepares for Wind Farms

Deputy Mayor Harley Greenfield is pushing Meaford council to explore proactive options that can be taken to protect constituents, despite the confines of the Green Energy Act.

Meaford Prepares for Wind Farms
Greenfield explains they want to know if creating a municipal by-law calling for a two kilometre setback from a residence could be enforceable, despite the GEA setback of just 550 metres.
However, Greenfield is adamant that even after they explore all financial and legal avenues -- Meaford will still not be in favour of wind development.
In fact, he plans to table a resolution next Monday to make that point very clear.
Greenfield adds that resolution won't overrule the Green Energy Act -- but it will let residents know exactly where council stands on the wind turbine issue.
Audio is posted, with the entire article, at the Bayshore Broadcasting website

Thursday, June 21, 2012

Why greens go in the red: How wind turbines and solar panels are making us poorer

Lorrie Goldstein's latest 

Why greens go in the red: How wind turbines and solar panels are making us poorer | Columnists | Opinion | Toronto Sun:
Ever notice how the places that are in the deepest financial trouble — Europe, California in the U.S., Ontario in Canada — are the ones that fell hardest for the myth of green energy?

While it would be inaccurate to attribute their mad rush into “renewables” as the sole cause of their fiscal woes — many reckless decisions led to that — it was certainly a contributing factor.

For one thing, wind turbines and solar panels, which only produce energy if massively subsidized by the state, drive up electricity prices, which kills off manufacturing jobs.
Read the entire article at the Toronto Sun website

Wimp Power: Some Quotations from Wind’s Critics

John Droz, Jr. has provided a contribution to the MasterResource blog listing selecting quotes about industrial wind power, including Jon Boone's; "“Windpower is not David to coal’s Goliath; rather, wind is David to coal’s Bathsheba”

Wimp Power: Some Quotations from Wind’s Critics — MasterResource:
Energy and environmental issues need to be addressed using logic and scientific thinking, not emotion, wishes, and depiction. On a realistic basis, industrial wind energy fails to deliver the goods. By this I mean that windpower:
  1. Is not a technically sound solution to provide us electricity, or to meaningfully reduce global warming, and
  2. Is not an economically viable source of energy on its own, and
  3. Is not environmentally responsible 
When you take away the wind lobbyists’ fast-talking shenanigans, their con comes down to these two things: They are telling us what we want to hear, and we’re not really verifying the truth of what they’re saying.
Read the quotes at MasterResource:

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Pinnacle noise complaint dismissed

A troubling story of the West Virginia Public Service Commission ruling, against their staff's direction, that excessive wind turbine noise was not within their jurisdiction to rule on, despite  previously claiming it was - and despite the turbines' owners attempts to curtail the sound.

Pinnacle noise complaint dismissed - Keyser, WV - Mineral Daily News-Tribune:
Braithwaite, who suffers from headaches and lack of sleep because of the ongoing noise problems, said he was disappointed but not surprised at the ruling. Someone higher up in state government put the screws to the PSC, which in turn rejected its own staff's recommendation and rolled over “the little guy” to do the bidding of the wind farm's corporate ownership, he said.
“The governor and all of them are pushing for wind farms, and the PSC backed down ...,” Braithwaite said. “They're not doing their job. That's all it is.”
Charlie Parnell, a spokesman for Edison, said Monday that studies conducted at Pinnacle found that the test muffler reduced noise significantly, and the company has ordered similar devices for the remaining 22 turbines. He expects the mufflers to be installed sometime this summer.
"We had significant reduction in noise (with the test muffler) and we anticipate significant reduction across the farm once they're all installed," he said.
Read the entire article at the Daily News-Tribune:

Turbine protestors make stand at consultation meeting in Bethany

Local coverage related to the final wpd public meeting in Bethany -- not the final stand against the Sumac Ridge proposal!

MyKawartha Article: Turbine protestors make final stand at consultation meeting:
"As far as we know, this is the first proposal that is being evaluated in the Oak Ridges Moraine," said Mr. Williams, pointing out that, with the Green Energy Act superceding the previous Oak Ridges Moraine policy, there will be no stopping other projects if Sumac Ridge moves forward.

Local MPP Laurie Scott - who was joined by Huron-Bruce MPP Lisa Thompson who made the four-hour drive to Bethany - urged everyone to not give up the fight.

"We need to make these companies understand that they're not welcome here," said Ms Scott during the rally which elicited applause and the comment 'they're not welcome anywhere' from within the crowd.

In support of the public, Ms Scott committed to maintaining pressure at Queen's Park "to oppose wind turbines for those municipalities that don't want them."

Ward 16 Coun. Heather Stauble encouraged people to send letters or e-mails of objection to the wind company - and copy her as well - and ask that the documents be included in the Renewable Energy Approval (REA) approval, which is the company's next step, and as part of the public record.
Read the entire article at myKawartha.com:

James Lovelock: on IWT's: ""ugly and useless they are"

The Guardian has posted more from it's latest interview with legendary British scientist, and creator of the Gaia theory, James Lovelock.  The comment thread indicates how controversial Mr. Lovelock's positions are, as does The Telegraph's James Delingpole reporting on the Guardian's interview:
A glorious interview with James Lovelock in today's Guardian. Essential reading for everyone, greens especially. In it, the inventor of Gaia theory and godfather of modern environmentalism declares that wind farms are hideous, renewables are a waste of space, nuclear power is good, sea level rises aren't a worry, environmentalism has replaced Christianity as the global religion and that we should all be "going mad on" shale gas, which he considers our best energy hope for the immediate future.

Cape Vincent to seek input on proposed restrictions for wind farms; hopes to adopt updated zoning law in August

Cape Vincent, New York, is active in trying to protect itself from BP's 200MW project ahead of New York's state passage of 'Article X' which is seen as pandering to large international wind/energy firms, such as BP (or Samsung, TransAlta, Suncor ....)

Watertown Daily Times | Cape Vincent to seek input on proposed restrictions for wind farms; hopes to adopt updated zoning law in August:
Proposed setbacks for large commercial turbines are:

■ Six times the total height of the proposed structure from the nearest residence, the nearest project boundary line, boundaries of adjacent towns and any road.

■ Two miles from Lake Ontario and St. Lawrence River waterfronts.

■ 1.25 miles from boundaries of the village of Cape Vincent and hamlets of Rosiere, Millens Bay and St. Lawrence Corners; from Route 12E; Seaway Trail; National Scenic Byways and schools.

A-weighted, audible spectrum, noise limits proposed are:

■ Daytime (7 a.m. to 7 p.m.), 45 dB.

■ Evening (7 to 10 p.m.), 40 dB.

■ Nighttime (10 p.m. to 7 a.m.), 35 dB
The noise limits are discussed in more detail in the full article.

New lines allow wind projects to plug in | London | News | London Free Press

John Miner's second column at the LFP site today notes the industrial wind projects that Hydro One's newly functional transmission line could facilitate (his other column reports on the large, and largely foreign, ownership of industrial wind).

New lines allow wind projects to plug in | London | News | London Free Press:
Completion of the biggest transmission line project in Ontario in 20 years clears an important hurdle for a series of massive wind turbine projects in Southwestern Ontario, including eight within 70 kilometres of London.
In the full article  Mr. Miner lists Jericho, Bornish, Goshen, Cedar Point, Adelaide, Gunn's Hill, Bluewater, St. Columban, Erieau, and East Lake St. Clair.

They sound homey — they aren’t

John Miner has an article covering the huge, primarily foreign, ownership of industrial wind projects (he has a second article reporting on the connection to new transmission capacity)

They sound homey — they aren’t | London | News | London Free Press:
The names have a comforting, familiar ring - Adelaide, Bluewater, Goshen, Bornish. Jericho.

But if you're looking for who controls the massive wind farms under development in this part of Ontario, you won't find their head office anywhere close to their local namesakes.

While incorporated as separate companies with local-$sounding names, the real control of these wind farms resides in Juno Beach, Fla., home to NextEra Energy, the third largest nuclear power company in the U.S. and the largest industrial wind company in North America.

NextEra Energy owns Florida Power and Light and NextEra Energy Resources, which owns NextEra Energy Canada. It, in turn, owns the planned Adelaide Wind Farm, as well as neighbouring Bornish, Goshen and Jericho.
Continue reading at the 'London Free Press'; the article includes quotes from WCO President Jane Wilson.

Tuesday, June 19, 2012

Niagara Regional Council Defeats Moratorium Motion

First ... a report in the local paper covering the Niagara Regional Council ...

Council by the numbers | Local | News | St. Catharines Standard:
THE HOT ISSUE: Wind turbines had regional councillors’ heads spinning Thursday as a proposed call by St. Catharines Coun. Andy Petrowski for a moratorium on new wind projects was defeated. The lopsided 18-6 vote didn’t reflect the long, drawn-out build up to it: Council spent about an hour in camera hearing from their legal beagles before several citizen delegations spent the next three hours airing their views, with citizens speaking fervently against the turbines and business reps arguing for them.  Read more at the St. Catharines Standard
The Wainfleet Wind Action Group provides the details on who voted for the moratorium motion (including NDP icon Peter Kormos, now a Welland councillor), and who voted against - while noting:
... the vote should be considered INVALID because of a conflict of interest:
NRC has a direct investment in Wind Energy!!! (Read more of "Niagara Regional Council fails, again!")

Samsung: Not playing nice in the [Wind] Yard

A Samsung consultant, Jason Chee-Aloy spoke out recently to John Spears in the Toronto Star about the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) and how they are giving his clients a rough time. He infers that his clients; Samsung, Pattern Energy Group, NextEra Energy Canada and IPR-GDF North America need to get IESO's blessing sooner to ensure their planned investments are not impacted. Chee-Aloy said “Things have to move faster,”. What Chee-Aloy sees as a risk is the possibility that industrial wind generation may be curtailed. He is also annoyed with the slowness of the approval process. The not so subtle, innuendo, is that these foreign entities will take their money and go home meaning, promised jobs wouldn't happen nor would targets for renewable energy, in the Long-Term Energy Plan (crafted as a “guide” by former Energy Minister, Brad Duguid) be achieved.

The missing part of Mr Chee-Aloy's concern was that consulting fees for his employer “Power Advisory LLC” (of Carlisle, Massachusetts) may also be at risk. Mr, Chee-Aloy's past life found him as the Director of Generation Procurement at the Ontario Power Authority where he was responsible for procuring over 13,000 MW of generation (the 2010 Sunshine list shows Mr. Chee-Aloy earned $132,176 and in 2009 he earned $176,931). Mr. Chee-Aloy also worked for IESO and should have been well aware of the issue he now says is causing all of the problems. It is labelled as SE-91 by IESO and is a committee that seeks to deal with the intermittent nature of wind generation (and our surplus power problems) perhaps even constraining IWTs without payment. So when Mr. Chee-Aloy was negotiating those OPA contracts would he have ensured that the Ontario ratepayers were protected by framing the contracts to do that; as his position would demand? One wonders if protecting Ontario ratepayers was on his mind or whether he was having visions of a bigger personal payday! One also wonders what the “conflict of interest” rules are that apply to Ontario's public service sector. My research on this took me to the Ontario Lobbyist Registry but a search for both Power Advisory LLC and Mr. Jason Chee-Aloy produced no results. Are our watchdogs watching is something that certainly came to mind as a visit to the Conflict of Interest Commissioner on Ontario's website states that former public servants are prohibited from a number of activities. In my opinion this appears to be a situation that needs to be looked at to determine if Mr. Chee-Aloy breached the “conflict of interest” rules.

Monday, June 18, 2012

Environmental Registry Issues Renewabale Energy Certificates

Friday, June 15th was dubbed Global Wind day and the Environmental Registry was active on it - issuing Renewable Energy Certificates for both the "Grand Renewable Energy Park" in Haldimand County (more reason to support Haldimand Wind Concerns), and the enormous South Kent Wind project in Chatham-Kent.  It was not a good day for the Boblink and Eastern Meadowlark in Haldimand County, or Manitoulin Island.
There is now a draft policy in the comment stage, regarding the use of public land for, presumably, private renewable energy projects.

More woes for people leasing land for turbines. Now, your insurer will quit on you, too.

A letter from an insurance  broker, noting the inability to insure a property due to a wind turbine, has been circulating.
  ... in regard to your inquiry about the installation of wind turbines on your property ...the Company has advised that should a wind turbine be erected on the property, the Western General would not insure same and they would no longer remain on risk at that property...

Pembina: The Money is Blowing in the Wind

Revised - see endnote
The Pembina Institute has enlisted Heidi Eijgel, neighbour to the Summerview Wind Farm in Pincher Creek, Alberta, to conduct a limited tour and speaking engagement in Ontario purportedly to dispel the thoughts of any problems associated with living next to industrial wind turbines.

The Pembina Institute is one of three related entities (that the writer could locate) and it is a not-for-profit! One of them; The Pembina Foundation for Environmental Research and Education is a charity and the Green Learning Canada Foundation is another not-for-profit. Limited financial information is available on the CRA Charities website for the “Foundation”. Green Learning Canada publishes no information but Pembina Institute publishes what they call an annual report. The information contained in it is very limited and would not pass muster with any accountant or bookkeeper. Despite that it does have some interesting information as do other parts of their website. The Trillium Foundation also reported they provided a $130,000 grant to the Pembina Institute for Appropriate Development but no information, financial or otherwise is available in the public domain. The Pembina Institute claims it provides research for the public and private sectors and the annual report shows revenue of $2.3 million in “fees for services” for the year ended December 31, 2010. Along those lines they recently released two reports; the first titled “In the Shadow of the Boom”; released May 30, 2012 examining the relationship on the Canadian economy with the Mulclair (NDP Leader) claim that Canada was afflicted with “Dutch Disease”. The conclusion of the study is that Canada has a “uniquely Canadian strain of the Dutch disease that could be called “oilsands fever”.

Audio Report on Waubra

 Compelling audio from Australia's national broadcaster, on the damage done, and ongoing fight, in Waubra.

Wind Farms |ABC (Australia)
More than 60 wind farms have sprung up across Australia in the last decade.
Giant white propellers scattered across hilltops around the country... 
We headed to the tiny town of Waubra, about two hours northwest of Melbourne to find a town divided by the farms.

Half of the residents have turbines and the added financial benefit.
The other half say the turbines are making their rural hamlet unliveable.

Dufferin eyes $4K per turbine fee

Dufferin is the latest jurisdiction to look at development charges for industrial wind turbines. 

Orangeville Article: Dufferin eyes $4K per turbine fee:
For example, a bylaw recently brought into effect by Grey County will start charging a flat rate of $5,000 per turbine starting next year. Once that phased-in approach comes into force, Grey will be eligible to collect nearly the same amount of DCs per wind turbine as it does for a single family home.
County officials had asked Bevan to suggest some alternatives to its GFA model. He presented council with three options on Thursday — stick with the GFA status quo, collect a rate of $1,127 per turbine or calculate charges based on volume.
Although Bevan wasn’t aware of any municipality in Ontario adopting a volumetric approach, council is eyeing that route.
The entire article may be read at Orangeville.com

Wind Turbines Violate Children's Rights

A new post on Amherst Island Wind Info presents a letter to the Editor of the Kingston Whig Standard.


Wind turbines Violate Children's Rights:
As parents of young children.and members of a fifth-generation Amhetst Island family. we are alarmed by the recent news release from Windelectric Inc. that states that industrial wind turbines on Amherst Island will be a “community benefit and improvement ..... for all residents.’ On behalf of our children. we disagree.

The United Nations Convetion on the Rights of the Child, which Canada has ratified, outlines the rights of children to health and safety; in particular. the convention emphasizes the obligation of adults and governments to protect the physical and mental health of children. 
Scientific evidence has demonstrated the negative health outcomes noise can have on the cardiovascular system, memory, language development. and learning acquisition of children.
Peer-reviewed literature cites growing evidence that children living in close proximity to wind turbines have demonstrated changes in sleep patterns, decline in academic performance and behaviour, and problems with concentration and memory. 

End of Subsidies for Big Wind On the Horizon

The Telegraph is reporting that David Cameron's government looks set to phase out subsidies by the end of the decade.

Subsidies for onshore wind farms 'to be axed by 2020'
Within weeks, Ed Davey, the Lib Dem Energy Secretary, will announce details of subsidies for renewable energy covering the period 2013-2017, following a consultation on whether they should be cut by more than the 10 per cent reductions already planned.

Mr Osborne is understood to be pressing Mr Davey for onshore subsidy cuts of around 25 per cent for that period.

Sunday, June 17, 2012

Haldimand Wind Concerns Appeal Continues

 Haldimand Wind Concerns has provided an update on their ERT hearing (last updated June 20th).   Please note their appeal, and visit the their website!
HWC's case at the Environmental Review Tribunal Hearing continues this week on
Wednesday, June 20 and Thursday, June 21 at the Hagersville Community Centre (62 Main St. South, Hagersville),and regular starting time is 10 am.

June 20 is planned for the Director, Vic Schroter who approved NextEra's project and
Ben Greenhouse, the project manager to testify and be questioned.

June 21 - MOE Motion

Then the Hearing continues on July 16, 17, 18 & 19. A date for summations for Bill
Monture's case and HWC's case still has to be determined.

Saturday, June 16, 2012

Government gold


Government gold:
Green energy, a clarion call to investment in Ontario's future, eventually may prove to have spawned more ostensibly job-related deals - all on taxpayers' backs - than even Bernie Madoff conjured.

Almost panic-like, the provincial government signalled its proactive-like policy decision in Ontario's infamous Green Energy Act by removing municipal control over zoning when it came to siting everything from massive wind turbines to solar panels.

Respectable investment brokerage firms advertised services to prospective green energy investors in terms reminiscent of newspaper ads about the 1890s Yukon gold rush.
Read the entire article at the Windsor Star Site

Friday, June 15, 2012

Robert Bryce: The Wind Lobby Is Powered by Fossil Fuels

Robert Bryce looks at the wind lobby and sees fossil fuel bodies.

Energy Tribune- The Wind Lobby Is Powered by Fossil Fuels:

Lobbyists for the wind-energy sector are actively lobbying for a multi-year extension of the production tax credit, the 2.2 cents per kilowatt-hour subsidy given to producers of wind-generated electricity. To justify that lucrative subsidy, which expires at the end of this year, the wind lobby continually portrays itself as being an alternative to fossil fuels.

Furthermore, the American Wind Energy Association’s spokesmen and their many boosters in the blogosphere regularly deride anyone who criticizes industrial wind projects as somehow being in the thrall of the fossil fuel sector. But their rhetoric doesn’t match reality. The hard truth is this: AWEA represents the fossil fuel industry.
Continue reading at Energy Tribune:

Tempers blow, profanity flows at turbine gathering

   Tempers blow, profanity flows at turbine gathering | Local | News | Chatham Daily News:
BLENHEIM - Profanity laced-tirades were heard as emotions ran high during a public meeting here about the health impacts of green energy projects.

More than 50 people attended the meeting at the Blenheim Community Golf Club, organized by the Chatham-Kent Wind Action Group. The topic was "Industrial Wind Turbines and Your Family Health."

Carmen Krogh, a retired pharmacist who has been researching the adverse effects on wind turbines on human health for the past four years, spoke about peer-reviewed studies that have shown increasing setbacks for industrial wind turbines to 2-kilometres has diminished complaints about negative impacts to human health.

Minimum setbacks for the majority of wind turbines in Chatham-Kent are 550 metres.
Read the entire article at the Chatham Daily News

Thursday, June 14, 2012

Renewable Energy vs. Responsible Aboriginal Government Part Three: M’Chigeeng vs. Wikwemikong Blowing in Opposite Directions | Tom Adams Energy - ideas for a smarter grid

Tom Adams has an extensive post today reviewing the situation there in laying the groundwork for a ceremony featuring David Suzuki and Minister Bentley, and the environmentalist protesters noted in the quoted section below

Renewable Energy vs. Responsible Aboriginal Government Part Three: M’Chigeeng vs. Wikwemikong Blowing in Opposite Directions | Tom Adams Energy - ideas for a smarter grid:
(Statement issued by Manitoulin Coalition for Safe Energy Alternatives, June 14, 2012)

MCSEA and Wikwemikong Elders, Community Members and Youth — groups well known for their opposition to Industrial Wind Turbine Projects on Manitoulin Island — will be protesting the opening of the M’Chigeeng industrial wind power project on June 15. 
M’Chigeeng community members who have concerns with the project but also have concerns about possible repercussions from M’Chigeeng Band Council should the opponents be seen protesting have specifically requested MCSEA and Wikwemikong citizens raise awareness, circulate information to the public, and conduct a peaceful protest.

The Wikwemikong group has restored democracy in their community and repeatedly halted industrial wind turbines by successfully petitioning their council. The democratic success of the Wikwemikong citizens contrast starkly the lack of democratic rights of other rural residents of Ontario who have had their right stripped away under the Green Energy and Green Economy Act.
The concerns of many M’Chigeeng citizens include the potential for additional turbines to be added in future, the loss of traditional hunting grounds, forest loss, the siting of the turbines in key habitat, loss of reserve lands for productive use due to the minimum 550 meter provincial danger zone setback from each turbine, and the concern that even this exclusion distance is totally inadequate to mitigate impacts.
Read the entire article at the Tom Adams Energy website:

Bruce Lourie`s Spider Web Captures Prey and Our Tax Dollars


Exploration of the Lourie connections continues (refer attached spider web) with an examination of two more of the Summerhill Group. The following examines the Summerhill “not-for-profit; Summerhill Impact and the “charity”; Summerhill Foundation. As noted in a previous article the 32 programs run by Summerhill Impact presumably have a resultant revenue implication on the full Summerhill Group but as little financial information is available in the public domain it is difficult to quantify.

View this web in.pdf format here
The only financial information accessible is for the charity via the CRA filings (Canada Revenue Agency) and one of the “Impact” programs (buried in the website) that provides any clue on costs to taxpayers. The “Retire Your Ride” (RYR) program was closed effective March 31, 2011, but during it's relatively short life (2009 appears to be the year it started) it has received in excess of $39 million from Environment Canada or $281 per automobile (138,671 cars claimed removed). Reviewing the financial statements of “Retire Your Ride” indicates that the Summerhill Group (not mentioned in the financial report) generated gross revenue of $406 per automobile. The excess of $125.00 per auto ($17,334,000) in the two years that the RYR operated paid for “Program delivery” ($8.3 million), “Marketing” ($5.5 million), “Professional Fees” ($1.6 million) and “Management Fees” ($1.3 million), and a few other expenses.

Wednesday, June 13, 2012

HWC appeal moves to Toronto

An Update from Haldimand Wind Concerns:
HWC's appeal will continue on Friday, June 15 at 9:30 am. at 655 Bay St. in Toronto. Expert witnesses Mr. Ambrose and Mr. Rand will be testifying via video conference on behalf of HWC during the morning session. In the afternoon, Dr. Dobie will testify on behalf of NextEra. Everyone who can attend would be greatly appreciated!
Thanks.
HWC

Chilly reception for Invenergy at Listowel public meeting

Andrew Smith has written a compelling, and very informative, report of the June 7th public meeting in Listowel, for the proposed Conestogo industrial wind project.  

Chilly reception for Invenergy at Listowel public meeting | Your online newspaper for Southwestern Ontario:
LISTOWEL – The term annoyance gets tossed around a lot when debating wind turbines. No matter what definition though, those in attendance for a public meeting in Listowel were clearly annoyed.
Nearly 200 people attended the first public information centre hosted by Invenergy Canada at the Royal Canadian Legion on June 7, in anticipation of their Conestogo Wind Power Partnership project in North Perth and Perth East.
James Murphy, director of development for Invenergy Canada, explained the proposed 69 MW project would position 27 turbines in the area, though the exact layout for the turbines is yet to be determined. Murphy was also unable to confirm the size of turbines to be used, but that it could be up to 3 MW...
Please Read the entire article at southwesternontario.ca

Turbines 'clearly' heard 2km away: report

A new Australian report recommends not only maintaining an existing 2 km setback requirement on new industrial wind turbine installations, but implementing the setback for existing IWT's.

Turbines 'clearly' heard 2km away: report - Weekly Times Now:
A REPORT into wind farm noise has recommended that turbines on existing wind farms less than 2km from housing be removed.

The Victorian Government last year introduced policy that states a wind farm cannot be located within 2km of an existing dwelling but turbines built near homes before the legislation was passed remain switched on.

A new report, released today by Noise Management Services, emphasises "the need for, and practicality of" the 2km setback.

"It is recommended that the 2km setback be implemented at Waubra, Cape Bridgewater and other existing wind farms," the report said.
The entire article can be read at the 'Weekly Times Now' website.:

Ontario offers lower hydro rates to industry

John Spears story in The Toronto Star accompanied the press release from the government.
Cheap abundant supply allows discounts to large industry at the same time as expensive intermittent supply is forced on unwelcoming communities at the expense of unwitted ratepayers.

Ontario offers lower hydro rates to industry for job creation - thestar.com:
Bentley said the low-cost power for businesses won’t cost other power users anything.

That’s because the power used for the program is surplus power that otherwise would have been exported, he said.

Ontario is sometimes forced to offer power to neighbouring states and provinces at a steep discount – and occasionally even pays them to take Ontario’s surplus.

“We’re not selling it at a loss, we are exporting our extra,” Bentley said. “We have sufficient generation for families and businesses of Ontario, the demand following the world-wide recession left us with extra, and we’re putting that extra to work.”

Bentley said Ontario can produce about 150,000,000 megawatt hours of electricity a year, but uses only 140,000,000.
The entire article can be read at thestar.com - where comments are currently open

Tuesday, June 12, 2012

Health issues raised in windfarm debate

Powerful testimony, in South Australia, detailing some health impacts one man experienced upon the arrival of industrial wind turbines

Health issues raised in windfarm debate - Local News - News - General - The Border Watch:
PULSING sensations in the head, ringing in the ears and nocturnal panic attacks are some of the symptoms which Millicent beef producer David Mortimer claims have led him to consider suicide.

Mr Mortimer almost broke down while giving evidence against Infigen Energy's proposed Woakwine Windfarm to Wattle Range Council's independent Development Assessment Panel (DAP).

The DAP welcomed comments from residents on Monday as part of the decision making process on the approval of the proposed windfarm.

"To have the continuous pulsing in your head, it is like your brain getting squeezed, you can't get away from it, there is no escape, I can put in ear plugs, but it is still there," Mr Mortimer said.

"I get nocturnal panic attacks at night - I don't know what I'm trying to get away from."

During the day Mr Mortimer experienced dizziness, feelings of his heart being in high speed "flutter" mode, fits of depression and wanted to go to sleep "and not wake up".

"I've considered suicide when I've been in a state of depression, and I've never been that way before," he said.
Read the entire article at The Border Watch website

Spanish company stops wind-turbine project - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Congratulations to the opponents who fought Gamesa's project for many years ... and to the Indiana bats!

Spanish company stops wind-turbine project - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette:
Gamesa Inc. has canceled a controversial wind-power project it planned to build on Shaffer Mountain in a major flyway for migrating hawks, eagles and bats along the border of Somerset and Bedford counties.

The Spanish company, which operates wind-turbine production facilities in Pennsylvania, announced it would abandon the project because of uncertain federal wind-power production subsidy policy and concerns the turbines could harm the endangered Indiana bat.
 Read the entire article in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette:

Wainfleet Wind Action Group | Call for Support on Moratorium Resolution

The Wainfleet Wind Action Group is urging support for a moratorium resolution due for a vote on June 14th.

Wainfleet Wind Action Group | Please Join the Fight: SubscribeWainfleet Wind Action Group | Please Join the Fight: Subscribe:
A Resolution for a Moratorium on IWT development is on the Agenda for the June 14/12 NRC meeting at 6:30pm.

Concerned residents and citizens of the Region should show in the largest possible numbers to show support for a Resolution.

A Phone Blitz is proposed on local and regional NRC members. Phone and Email info can be found here.

When a Plan is not a Plan-The truth behind the Integrated Power System Plan

The Ontario Power Authority (OPA) had a specific purpose when created by the Ontario Liberals in 2005 as a temporary agency—develop a long term Integrated Power System Plan (IPSP).  The OPA produced the “plan” but when George Smitherman created Bill 150, the Green Energy and Economy Act, he told the OPA to shelve the plan.

When Smitherman left to run unsuccessfully for the Toronto mayoralty position he was replaced by Brad Duguid as the Minister of Energy and on November 23, 2010 the Ministry issued “Ontario's Long-Term Energy Plan” (LTEP) as a “guide”. Minister Duguid followed this guide with a February 17, 2011 directive to the OPA to develop an “integrated power system plan” or IPSP II. The OPA dutifully complied and (according to my sources at the OPA) delivered the new IPSP to the Ministry of Energy “for review”. The actual delivery date appears to have been just prior to the Provincial election date of October 7, 2011 and it now appears it was not reviewed by either Brad Duguid or the new Energy Minister, Chris Bentley. The second plan has gone the way of the first IPSP and has now presumably been shredded and recycled without any review as the following explains.

The recent announcement by the Minister that the OPA would be merged with the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) has resulted in the need for “Bill 75”, that now is in the process of 2nd reading in the Ontario Legislature. Bill 75 includes the following section:

“40. (2) Clause 70 (2) (l) of the Act is amended by striking out “an integrated power system plan” and substituting “an energy plan”.